Geoffrey is actually slain from inside the a riding accident during the 1186 and you may Constance partnered (2) Ranulph de- Blundeville, 4 th Earl out-of Chester, towards the step 3 rd February 1188, within the a married relationship setup because of the King Henry 11. So it relationships deteriorated and you will Ranulph imprisoned Constance in the 1196. Rebellions had been stimulated across the Brittany on the and you will Ranulph put out their own into the 1198. Back to Brittany, Constance got her relationships annulled and later within the 1198, she took Guy de Trips because the their own ‘second’ spouse.

Constance passed away old forty, (possibly away from leprosy, perhaps following childbirth so you can twin girls) into the 5 th September 1201 during the Nantes

Even though this wasn’t good consanguineous dating but certainly one of affinity, one first-degree relationships could have rendered wedding anywhere between Constance and you can any of John’s brothers impossible without an effective dispensation –– hence because of the party’s score might have needed to are from the new pope himself

The theory one Constance got an affair which have John following death of Geoffrey and just before John’s wedding so you’re able to Isabella of Gloucester within the 1189, and this she is actually mom so you’re able to Joanna is very contentious and possess provoked much talk within genealogical groups.

One to opinion from an effective genealogist states one ‘this new diary ‘New Plantagenet Connection’ provides had written an ahnentafel off E Plantagenet, wife from Henry V11, which provides Joanna’s mom’s identity once the Constance (possibly misnamed Clemence?), Duchess off Brittany. This is actually the Constance who was John’s sis-in-legislation! Due to the really-known animosity between John and you can Constance along with her very own tries to drive their unique young man Arthur’s interests as far as new throne from England is actually concerned (and we also all of the understand how disastrously you to proved!), I must say i get the proposed dating a little difficult to ingest. The brand new Constance you to record portrays doesn’t struck me because the to the which John can potentially coerce for the bed.’

‘ An idea who would select Joanna’s mother once the Constance doesn’t take into account a very critical part of canon legislation. Who would mean that particular shade of one’s amount need undoubtedly have come down seriously to us, if this inside it the fresh obtain it, the newest deliberations, or even the real dispensation alone. In so far as i have always been aware, little of your form is available.’

Of the only with sex that have John, aside from bearing your a baby, Constance could have built a primary-degree matchmaking out-of attraction with all John’s siblings –– also John’s brother Geoffrey

My personal viewpoint for what it’s worth, would be the fact had Constance already been the mother of Joanna she would positively features brought her right up in her own home along with her label might be also called Constance’s most other pupils from the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Reasonable Maid regarding Brittany, Matilda/Maud from Brittany and you may Arthur).

Agatha came into this world on 1168 inside Chartley Palace, Staffordshire. It is well known one she try a mistress from John and many members of the family woods render their unique, regardless if unmarried, while the mom away from Joanna. Extremely genealogists although not believe it is only conjecture you to this woman is Joanna’s mommy because the no proof or records are present to show this.

You to definitely source seem to offered is Sir William Dugdale, regarding Baronage away from England (1675-6). He says his provider is Dr David Howell’s ‘Reputation of Wales’ (1584). Powell’s work is an increased release regarding H Lloyd’s translation off ‘The fresh Historie of Cambria’ by the a dozen th century Saint Caradoc of Llancarfan. A different resource, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ by the Charles Browning, copyright laws 1969 as well as names Agatha de Ferrers, child regarding Robert de Ferrers, 4th Earl out of derby, once the Joanna’s mommy.

Regardless if she cannot be Formosa girls for marriage completely overlooked since an applicant for mom regarding Joanna, definitely there would be specific shade regarding their unique in a chronicle or other historical site, when the she had actually become mom of one’s partner out of new Prince away from North Wales.